How Scientific Prayer Changed the Way I Think About Praying
- Georgia Clare
- Jul 12
- 12 min read
Exploring Joseph Murphy’s idea of scientific prayer and why it completely changed my understanding of belief, the subconscious mind and the quiet conversations we have with ourselves.
The Question I Couldn’t Stop Thinking About
For most of my life, prayer meant asking.
Asking for guidance.
Asking for strength.
Asking for protection.
Sometimes asking for things to change.
It was something I had done since I was a child, and like many people, I never really questioned what prayer was or how it worked. I just accepted the explanation I’d been given.
It wasn’t until much later in life, after leaving the strict religious community I had belonged to for so many years, that I felt able to explore different ideas with an open mind.
That journey led me to many fascinating writers, psychologists and philosophers. Some I agreed with. Others challenged me. A few completely changed the way I thought about the world.
One of those writers was Joseph Murphy.
If you’ve come across his work before, you’ll know he often talks about something he calls scientific prayer. It’s a phrase that sounds almost contradictory. Prayer feels deeply spiritual. Science feels objective and measurable. At first glance, the two don’t seem to belong together.
I was curious.
Not because I was looking for another belief system to replace the one I’d left behind.
If anything, I had become wary of people claiming to have all the answers.
What interested me was the psychology behind his ideas.
One passage, in particular, stopped me in my tracks.
Murphy pointed out that people from every religion pray.
Christians pray.
Jews pray.
Muslims pray.
Hindus pray.
Buddhists pray.
People from indigenous traditions pray.
Many spiritual people who don’t belong to any organised religion pray too.
Each believes, in their own way, that their prayers can be answered.
His question was simple.
If different religions pray to different understandings of God, or different deities altogether, who, or what, is answering those prayers?
That was an aha moment for me.
Not because I suddenly thought he had solved one of humanity’s oldest questions.
But because I realised I had never considered it before.
It wasn’t the answer that fascinated me.
It was the question.
For years, I’d assumed prayer was something that happened outside of me.
I spoke.
Someone listened.
Something happened.
Or it didn’t.
Murphy invited me to consider a completely different possibility.
What if the greatest power of prayer wasn’t about persuading an external force to change our circumstances?
What if it was changing us?
That idea stayed with me.
Not because I accepted it immediately, but because I started noticing it in my own life.
When I looked back over the periods where I’d felt most peaceful, most hopeful or most present, I realised something.
Those weren’t necessarily the times when my circumstances had been easiest.
They were the times when my inner world was calm.
The relationship between what I repeatedly thought, what I believed and how I experienced my life suddenly became much more interesting than the question of whether my prayers had been “answered” in the way I’d expected.
Over the next few months, I found myself reading more widely.
Not just Joseph Murphy, but psychology, neuroscience and books about habit formation.
Although they used very different language, I began noticing a common thread.
Our thoughts matter.
The stories we tell ourselves matter.
The beliefs we rehearse every day matter.
That doesn’t mean we can simply think our way out of every difficulty.
Life is more complicated than that.
Heartbreak still hurts.
Loss still hurts.
Illness still happens.
Unexpected challenges still arrive.
I’m naturally sceptical of anyone who suggests that positive thinking alone can solve every problem. I don’t believe life works like that.
But I do believe our inner dialogue shapes the way we meet those problems.
Two people can experience the same situation and walk away with completely different stories about what it means.
One sees failure.
Another sees learning.
One sees rejection.
Another sees redirection.
The event is the same.
The interpretation is different.
And often, it’s that interpretation that influences what happens next.
That’s one of the reasons the idea of scientific prayer resonated so deeply with me.
Not because it promised miracles.
Because it asked me to pay attention to something I actually had some influence over.
My own mind.
The phrase scientific prayer can sound a little misleading if you’ve never heard it before.
Despite the name, it isn’t a scientifically proven technique in the way a medical treatment or laboratory experiment might be. Joseph Murphy used the term because he believed there were consistent principles at work whenever we repeatedly impressed an idea upon the subconscious mind.
Whether you agree with all of his conclusions or not, modern psychology does support several related ideas.
We know that repeated thoughts strengthen neural pathways.
We know our expectations influence our behaviour.
We know our brains naturally look for evidence that confirms what we already believe.
In other words, what we repeatedly think about doesn’t simply stay inside our heads.
It quietly shapes the way we see the world.
That, for me, was the beginning of a very different understanding of prayer.
Not as a list of requests.
Not as a negotiation.
But as a daily practice of becoming more aware of the thoughts, emotions and beliefs I was feeding into my own subconscious.
It didn’t change overnight.
In fact, I didn’t even realise it was happening at first.
But slowly, my morning routine began to look very different.
From Asking to Becoming
As my understanding began to change, so did the way I approached prayer.
For years, my prayers had been centred on changing my circumstances.
Please let this work.
Please help me.
Please make things better.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with praying like that. When life feels overwhelming, reaching out in hope is one of the most natural things we can do.
But I began to notice something.
Almost all of my prayers were focused on what I didn’t have.
I was praying from lack.
From fear.
From uncertainty.
My attention wasn’t on peace. It was on the absence of peace.
It wasn’t on abundance. It was on not having enough.
It wasn’t on healing. It was on everything that felt broken.
Joseph Murphy suggested that the subconscious mind responds not so much to the words we repeat, but to the dominant beliefs, feelings and emotions behind them.
Whether you see that through a spiritual lens, a psychological one, or somewhere in between, I think there’s something worth paying attention to.
Have you ever noticed that when you’re worried about something, your mind seems to find endless evidence that your worry is justified?
Equally, when you’re excited about a new opportunity, you begin spotting possibilities that you might never have noticed before.
The world hasn’t changed overnight.
Your attention has.
Modern psychology offers several ways of understanding this.
Our brains are constantly filtering information. Every second we’re exposed to far more sights, sounds and experiences than we could ever consciously process. Instead, our minds decide what deserves our attention.
One of the things that influences that process is what we repeatedly think about.
If you’ve ever bought a new car and then suddenly noticed the same model everywhere, you’ll know exactly what I mean. Those cars weren’t absent before. Your brain simply hadn’t considered them important enough to notice.
I sometimes wonder whether our beliefs work in much the same way.
When we repeatedly tell ourselves that opportunities never come our way, our minds become remarkably good at finding evidence to support that belief.
When we repeatedly remind ourselves that we’re capable of learning, adapting and finding solutions, we begin noticing different possibilities.
That isn’t magic.
It isn’t wishful thinking.
It’s one of the reasons our mindset matters so much.
For me, scientific prayer gradually became less about asking for external change and more about creating internal alignment.
Instead of beginning the day with anxious thoughts about everything that might go wrong, I started creating a different morning ritual.
I would make a cup of tea.
Sit quietly before looking at my phone.
Take a few slow, intentional breaths.
Usually I’d meditate.
Sometimes I’d simply close my eyes and imagine how I wanted to feel by the end of the day.
Not what I wanted to own.
Not what I wanted to achieve.
Just how I wanted to be.
Peaceful.
Calm.
Patient.
Creative.
Hopeful.
Then I’d spend a few moments imagining myself moving through the day as that version of me.
At first, it felt a little unusual.
Almost too simple.
But over time, I realised I wasn’t trying to convince the universe to give me something.
I was gently teaching my own mind what to expect from me.
That distinction changed everything.
One of the biggest misconceptions about ideas like scientific prayer is that they’re often presented as a way of getting whatever you want.
I don’t believe that’s what life is about.
I’ve prayed for things that never happened.
I’ve hoped for outcomes that never came to pass.
I’ve experienced heartbreak that no amount of positive thinking could prevent.
Life doesn’t always unfold according to our plans.
Scientific prayer, at least as I understand it today, isn’t about controlling life.
It’s about influencing the one part of life we have the greatest opportunity to shape: our own thoughts, attitudes and responses.
That may not sound as exciting as promises of instant manifestation, but I think it’s far more empowering.
Because while we can’t control every circumstance, we can become more aware of the beliefs we’re reinforcing each day.
Are we rehearsing fear?
Or courage?
Scarcity?
Or gratitude?
Hopelessness?
Or possibility?
Those aren’t questions with right or wrong answers.
They’re invitations to become curious about the stories running quietly in the background of our minds.
One of my favourite insights from Murphy’s work is that desire alone isn’t enough.
If one part of us longs for change while another part is convinced it will never happen, those conflicting beliefs create tension.
I recognised that in myself immediately.
I wanted to believe that life could be joyful again after my marriage ended.
But another voice whispered that perhaps the best years of my life were behind me.
Those two beliefs couldn’t comfortably exist together.
Slowly, through writing, meditation, gratitude and this new understanding of prayer, I began feeding a different story.
Not a fantasy.
Not blind optimism.
A quieter, steadier belief that healing was possible, even if I couldn’t yet see the whole path.
Looking back, I think that’s what scientific prayer gave me more than anything else.
Not certainty.
Not guarantees.
Hope.
And sometimes hope is enough to help us take the next small step.
Then another.
And another.
Until one day we realise we’ve quietly become someone we never imagined we could be.
The Quiet Conversations That Shape Our Lives
One of the biggest lessons I’ve learned over the past few years is that we are all in conversation all day long.
Not with other people.
With ourselves.
Sometimes we notice those conversations.
Often we don’t.
“I’m not good enough.”
“Things never work out for me.”
“I always get things wrong.”
“I’m too old to start again.”
Or perhaps they’re kinder.
“I’ll find a way.”
“I’ve survived difficult things before.”
“I don’t have to have everything figured out today.”
“I can learn.”
Those quiet sentences matter more than we realise because we hear them far more frequently than anything anyone else says to us.
If you repeat a thought often enough, it begins to feel like the truth.
Not necessarily because it is true.
But because it’s familiar.
That’s one of the reasons I now think scientific prayer is much bigger than prayer itself.
It’s about becoming conscious of the stories we’re rehearsing.
Whether you pray, meditate, journal, visualise, spend time in nature or simply sit quietly with a cup of tea each morning, you’re creating space to notice your inner world.
And once you notice it, you have a choice.
You don’t have to believe every thought that passes through your mind.
That realisation was incredibly freeing for me.
For years I assumed my thoughts were facts.
If I felt afraid, there must be danger.
If I doubted myself, perhaps I wasn’t capable.
If I imagined the worst, maybe I was simply being realistic.
Now I see those thoughts differently.
They are possibilities.
Not prophecies.
Visitors.
Not permanent residents.
That doesn’t mean I never experience fear or doubt.
Of course I do.
I’m human.
The difference is that I no longer automatically hand them the microphone.
Instead, I try to ask a gentler question.
Is this the story I want to keep practising?
Sometimes the answer is yes.
Perhaps my anxiety is alerting me to something important.
Sometimes the answer is no.
Perhaps it’s simply an old pattern trying to keep me safe in ways that no longer serve me.
That question has changed countless ordinary moments.
It changes the way I begin my mornings.
It changes how I respond when something unexpected happens.
It changes the conversations I have with myself after making a mistake.
Little by little, those moments accumulate.
Looking back, I don’t think the biggest changes in my life came from dramatic decisions.
They came from small daily practices repeated over months and years.
Writing in my journal.
Meditating.
Keeping a gratitude journal.
Walking through the forest near my home.
Reading books that stretched my thinking.
Learning to replace self-criticism with curiosity.
None of those habits felt life-changing on a single day.
Together, they quietly rebuilt my life.
Perhaps that’s why the phrase scientific prayer still stays with me.
Not because I think it’s the perfect name.
But because it reminds me that what we repeatedly think, feel and believe matters.
It matters because those thoughts influence our choices.
Our choices become our habits.
Our habits shape our lives.
Whether we see that process as psychology, spirituality, neuroscience or simply part of being human, the principle feels remarkably similar.
We become, little by little, the person we repeatedly practise being.
Today, if someone asked me whether I believe in prayer, I’d probably smile before answering.
I’d say I believe in intentional moments of stillness.
I believe in paying attention to the conversations happening inside my own mind.
I believe in gratitude.
I believe in visualising the kind of person I want to become.
I believe in the extraordinary ability of human beings to learn, adapt and begin again.
I believe that peace grows when we practise peace.
That hope grows when we practise hope.
That compassion grows when we practise compassion.
And whether you choose to call that prayer, meditation, intention or something else entirely doesn’t really matter to me.
The label is far less important than the practice.
Because every day we’re planting seeds.
Through our thoughts.
Our words.
Our attention.
Our habits.
Some seeds grow fear.
Others grow hope.
The beautiful thing is that every morning offers us another opportunity to decide which ones we’d like to water.
Perhaps that’s what changed most for me.
I stopped asking life to become different before I could feel peaceful.
Instead, I began practising peace first.
Ironically, that was when my experience of life began to change.
Not because every circumstance became easier.
But because I did.
And maybe that’s the quiet power behind scientific prayer.
Not that it changes the world overnight.
But that, over time, it gently changes the person who walks through it.
A Gentle Reflection
If this article has given you something to think about, you might like to spend a few quiet minutes with these questions. There are no right or wrong answers, just an invitation to become more aware of the conversations you’re already having with yourself.
When I feel overwhelmed, what do I most often say to myself?
Are my thoughts helping me move towards the life I want, or keeping me rooted in fear?
If I believed that life was working with me rather than against me, how would today be different?
What quality would I like to practise more intentionally this week, peace, hope, courage, patience or gratitude?
What is one small daily ritual I could begin that helps me return to that feeling?
Sometimes we think change begins with one big decision. More often, it begins with one quiet thought, repeated often enough that it becomes a new way of seeing the world.
Continue Exploring
Your Literary Prescription
One of the reasons I created Book Quote Therapy is because I’ve experienced firsthand how the right book can quietly change the way we think. Sometimes it isn’t the whole story that stays with us, but a single sentence that gently shifts our perspective.
If this article resonated with you, I recommend exploring the Hope Literary Prescription.
It’s a carefully curated collection of books, poems and quotations that remind us that hope isn’t about denying reality or pretending life is easy. It’s about believing that a different future is possible, even when we can’t yet see the whole path.
If you’re visiting Book Quote Therapy for the first time, you’ll also find the free Literary First Aid Kit. A free collection of 50 quotes, poems and book recommendations designed to offer comfort, encouragement and fresh perspective whenever life feels uncertain.
Sometimes the words we need don’t give us all the answers.
They simply help us ask better questions.
Explore my Meditation Library
Meditation has become one of the most important parts of my own daily practice. If you’d like to create more space for stillness, clarity and intentional thinking, you’ll find a growing collection of guided meditations to support you, whether you’re seeking inner peace, greater focus, emotional healing or a fresh perspective.
You may enjoy the newest meditation I've just added - When Life Feels Stuck
If you’re looking for a simple way to build a daily practice, my Inner Peace Toolkit brings together guided meditations, reflective journalling, affirmation art and practical resources to help you cultivate a calmer, more positive inner world, one small step at a time.
Enjoyed this article?
If you’d like more reflections like this, I’d love to stay in touch.
Every week I share thoughtful articles, new meditations, Literary Prescriptions and practical ideas to help you create a calmer, more intentional life.
Join the Georgia Clare Newsletter and I’ll send them straight to your inbox.
Wherever you are on your journey, remember this:
You become, little by little, the person you repeatedly practise being. Choose your thoughts with kindness, your attention with intention, and trust that small daily moments have the power to create extraordinary change.
If this article found you at the right time, perhaps it will find someone else too.
Leaving a comment, sharing it, or simply clicking the ❤️ helps more people discover it, and I’d genuinely love to hear what you think.
Comments